Case Study

CAAPIC Chicago

The Chicago chapter of CAAPIC (Coalition for Asian American and Pacific Islander Churches) launched a cohort-model learning community to develop engaged AAPI Christian young adults (ages 18-35) to understand political power and practice the skills of community organizing.

CAAPIC Chicago

Context

CAAPIC begins with a set of wonderful presumptions that its work attempts to make good on.

It presumes that Asian Americans as diasporic, migrant, community-oriented people naturally dispose themselves to forms of political organizing, organizing as they say for power. It presumes that Asian American Christians carry these dispositions into their Christianity, and their Christianity proves effectual in both honing and expressing those dispositions.

It presumes that such forms of organizing are crucially important for democratic life, including the kinds of democratic life that have come under extraordinary and by all accounts unprecedented pressures in recent years. And then it presumes that the Asian American disposition toward organizing, and Christianity as Asian American organizing’s natural home, can meet the needs for democratic life in the current moment. CAAPIC takes these presumptions and tries to make good on it by creating a relational structure that catalyzes those dispositions, expressions and opportunities.

CAAPIC Chicago

CAAPIC’s Work with Northern Virginia Hamkae Center

Hamkae Center is comprised of East Asian American Christians who began organizing around issues of immigration, which those extraordinary political pressures have made one of the most important issues of our politics. Carrying those same presumptions that CAAPIC proceeds with, Hamkae Center convened gatherings looking to resource faith-based community organizing around immigration.

CAAPIC was not the source of this initiative. Neither did it want to be, since it is part of CAAPIC’s calling to come alongside emerging and ongoing work, not to imagine or initiate it.

Once alongside, CAAPIC offers resources that help what is already there grow. An important result of this partnership was a gathering where Hamkae Center’s immigration work benefited from CAAPIC’s resources, including relational networks, that tied the work to a national organization that could both inform and be informed by the Hamkae’s on-the-ground efforts.

Images from this partnership show a coalition of like-minded Christians mobilized around an important societal issue that both Hamkae and CAAPIC consider of vital importance to the democratic spirits of American Christianity, especially when lent into that Christianity’s Asian American personality and history.

CAAPIC’s story here also show the challenges that come with these opportunities, including the seemingly ever-present challenge of diversity of opinion, especially within an evangelicalism that continues to struggle with difference (both within its organs and beyond them). But the challenges also highlight the possibilities. These are challenges that arise in the democratic work of gathering and mobilizing, and in some significant sense only arise and reveal themselves in the heat of shared work and life.

CAAPIC Chicago

Challenges

The very things that make CAAPIC fresh and interesting and powerful—say, its youthful exuberance and vitality—are also the things that make its work challenging. You can’t have the fresh/interesting/powerful without the challenges. They are mutual entailments.

CAAPIC took its intuitional presumptions and looked for ways to make good on them. Those presumptions are not universally shared, and so CAAPIC’s efforts here were necessarily novel, and adventurous.

While faith-based organizing has a long and storied history in American Christianity, CAAPIC’s particular efforts arrive as new. That newness comes with its own challenges, and, again, the very thing that makes it vital with youthful energy means that there is much room to grow. The challenges here say as much about CAAPIC’s youthfulness as it does with the inhospitality of those systems, structures and institutions that CAAPIC already presumes as needing help.

In other words, the need for democratic revitalization that CAAPIC thinks Asian Americans especially capable of addressing proves true. Structures, systems and institutions are old, stubborn, becoming over time innately oppressive. They are old wine skins. Something like CAAPIC and the needs it tries to meet are new wine skin.

“The challenges here say as much about CAAPIC’s youthfulness as it does with the inhospitality of those systems, structures and institutions that CAAPIC already presumes as needing help.”

CAAPIC’s ambitions come in bursting old wine skins with the new wine of religiously-inspired Asian American democratic life, where the democracy and the Christianity are mutually-emerging coterminous powers. Their realization both gives new life to these structures, systems and institutions—include those revolving around immigration—and problematizes them, where the revitalization and the problematizing go together.

You can’t have one without the other, and CAAPIC’s great ambition and courage is to sit down in the middle between these two things. Which is both no easy thing, and the stuff, CAAPIC thinks, of life. 

The Challenges of a New Organization

But the problems in this space loom. Take for example one challenge CAAPIC faced in these early years of its life. As a new organization doing new things in new ways, it doesn’t fit the mold of how things organizationally get done in America, where things like business addresses for non-profits and bank accounts through which funds pass (or don’t) are part of the old-wine features that both enable good work, and often impedes it.

CAAPIC is still figuring out what it wants to be, a novel coolness still figuring out its identity. To commit too quickly to becoming a 503(c) with requisite business address and bank account tempts foreclosing all CAAPIC could still become. And yet, without a physical address and a bank account, it can’t get off the ground on so many things it wants and needs to do, like partner with an entity like Hamkae Center, which as an organization tied to other organizations to which it has responsibilities (including fudiciary ones i.e., those duties that come with business address and bank accounts) requires CAAPIC operate like they do.

Similarly to those organizations looking to be a resources to CAAPIC as CAAPIC is a resources to the Hamkae Centers of the world. The simple principle applies, but in the other direction. A sponsor might look to help CAAPIC help Hamkae, but it, like Hamkae needs CAAPIC to be a certain thing in the world (mailing address and bank account in hand). If CAAPIC settles into those structural, systematic and institutional needs, it can “do business” as it were, but, as stated, by acquiescing to those needs, doing business comes at the cost of delimitinig CAAPIC’s possibilities. The basic difficulty here is one all change agents face: how much does one become what one seeks to change in order to change it, what is lost and what is gained, how does new wine life iin old wine skins?

Part of the challenge, but also the wonder, of the early work of a CAAPIC is that such questions can hardly be answered ahead of time. They can only be properly assessed much less addressed in the thick of things, similarly to CAAPIC’s whole vision for democratic Christian life. It is CAAPIC’s conviction that Asian American are especially well-positioned to see these things, and make good on them. 

Scroll to Top